Breaking news

Copyright Law Struggles To Keep Up With AI Training

Courts Are Still Applying Old Copyright Rules To AI

AI companies train models on enormous amounts of published material, including books, articles and academic research. Whether using that content without authors’ permission violates copyright law remains unresolved.

Much of the debate centres on fair use, which allows copyrighted material to be used without permission in certain circumstances. Courts consider factors such as the purpose of the use, how much material was involved and its impact on the original market.

Anthropic Case Sets An Important Precedent

A major case involving Anthropic and a group of authors provided one of the clearest rulings so far. Judge William Alsup found that using copyrighted books to train AI models was lawful, comparing the process to people reading and studying literature before creating something new.

Anthropic was nevertheless ordered to pay $1.5 billion in a settlement. The penalty concerned books the company had obtained from illegal online libraries rather than the AI training itself.

For AI companies, that distinction could prove significant because it separates studying copyrighted material from directly copying it.

Competition Could Be The Key Issue

A case involving Thomson Reuters and Ross Intelligence offers a different perspective. A court ruled that Ross could not claim fair use after using Reuters’ copyrighted material to develop a competing AI-powered legal research platform.

The decision suggests courts may be less willing to consider AI training fair use when copyrighted content is used to build a product that directly competes with the original.

For authors, an unresolved question is whether AI-generated content should be considered competition for the works used to train these models.

The Law Has Yet To Catch Up

US copyright law predates generative AI by decades, leaving courts to apply old principles to new technology. Questions also remain over copyright protection for AI-generated works. In Thaler v. Perlmutter, a court ruled that material created entirely by AI cannot receive copyright protection.

Major AI companies remain involved in copyright litigation, and different courts could reach different conclusions. For now, there is no universal rule: the legality of AI training will depend on the circumstances of each case and how courts ultimately interpret copyright and fair use.

Cyprus Depositors Lag Behind As Mortgage Costs Rise, CBC Data Shows

Cyprus households are earning relatively modest returns on their savings even as mortgage borrowing costs climb again, according to new Central Bank of Cyprus data that places the country among the euro area’s weakest performers on deposit rates.

Deposits Rise, But Remain Near The Bottom Of The Euro Area

The central bank’s latest analysis, covering August 2026, found that the interest rate on new household deposits with agreed maturities of up to one year increased to 1.35 per cent from 1.27 per cent in July. Over the same period, the average rate on new house purchase loans rose sharply to 4.16 per cent from 3.78 per cent.

The contrast underscores a persistent imbalance in how interest rate changes are being transmitted across Cyprus’s banking system. While borrowers have felt the impact of higher rates more directly, savers continue to receive returns that remain unusually low by euro area standards.

The CBC said deposit rates in Cyprus sit at the lower end of the euro area and remain an outlier. The transmission of market interest rate changes to deposits has also been weaker in Cyprus than in almost every other euro area country, affecting both households and businesses.

Borrowing Costs Are Closer To The Euro Area Median

The picture on the lending side is more mixed. Interest rates on outstanding loans and on new lending are broadly aligned with the euro area median.

According to the CBC, the interest rate on outstanding loans to households in Cyprus was only 0.1 percentage points below the euro area median, while the corresponding rate for non-financial corporations was 0.3 percentage points above it. For new lending, the weighted average rate on loans to households for house purchase was 0.2 percentage points below the euro area median, while the rate for non-financial corporations was 0.1 percentage points lower.

Still, the latest monthly data show a notable increase in mortgage pricing in August. The average rate on house purchase loans rose to 4.16 per cent, from 3.78 per cent in July. The CBC noted that this is a weighted average across different types of housing loans, including mortgages for primary residences and holiday homes.

Because the composition of banks’ housing loan portfolios changes from month to month, weighted averages can move even when the underlying rates offered by banks have not shifted by the same amount.

Consumer Credit Rises, Business Lending Eases

Consumer borrowing also became more expensive, with the average interest rate rising to 7.12 per cent in August from 6.94 per cent in July.

For businesses, the trend was more favourable. The rate on loans of up to €1 million edged down to 4.45 per cent from 4.47 per cent, while the rate on loans above €1 million fell more sharply to 3.67 per cent from 4.29 per cent.

Even so, new lending volumes fell significantly across the board in August. Pure new lending dropped to €251.40m from €415.00m in July, while total new lending, which includes refinancing and other operations, declined to €390.10m from €686.10m.

Pure new consumer loans fell to €19.30m from €23.90m, and total lending in that category slipped to €20.70m from €26.50m. Pure new house purchase loans fell to €114.40m from €149.50m, while total lending for house purchases declined to €141.90m from €205.80m.

Business lending also slowed. Pure new loans of up to €1 million declined to €35.50m from €52.30m, while pure new lending above €1 million fell to €77.00m from €162.30m.

Why Cyprus Deposits Stay Low

The CBC’s euro area comparison is especially telling for savers. Unlike lending rates, the interest rates on existing deposits in Cyprus remain near the bottom of the euro area, which the central bank described as an outlier.

The CBC attributed this in part to the high level of excess liquidity held by Cypriot credit institutions. Cyprus’ Liquidity Coverage Ratio stood at 313 per cent in August 2026, compared with a median of 182 per cent and an EU average of 158 per cent in June 2026, the latest available figures cited by the central bank.

The relatively short maturity structure of Cyprus’s banking sector was also identified as a factor weighing on deposit rates. Rates offered on new deposits are similarly subdued and remain close to those paid on existing balances, reflecting the same underlying market conditions.

In practical terms, this means the European Central Bank’s monetary policy cycle has affected borrowing costs in Cyprus more visibly than it has improved returns for depositors. Savers have received only a limited pass-through of higher interest rates, even as borrowers have faced higher costs.

Mortgage Preferences Are Changing

The CBC also highlighted a marked shift in the type of mortgage borrowing being taken out by Cypriot households.

The share of new house purchase loans carrying a variable interest rate has fallen dramatically, from almost 100 per cent at the beginning of 2022 to just 12.0 per cent in August 2026. That is now below the euro area median.

The central bank said this may partly reflect borrowers opting for fixed-rate loans for an initial period, typically three to five years, before switching to floating rates. The shift suggests households are becoming more conscious of interest rate risk, a development banks will need to reflect in their risk management frameworks.

A similar trend is visible when household and business loans are viewed together. The share of new loans to households and non-financial corporations carrying floating rates has dropped from almost 100 per cent at the beginning of 2022 to 55.9 per cent in August 2026, below the euro area median. The CBC said this could again partly be explained by fixed-rate periods early in the life of a loan, before conversion to floating rates later on.

The Bottom Line For Savers And Borrowers

For households, the latest data point to a mixed picture. Mortgage rates remain broadly comparable with the euro area, but deposit returns remain unusually low, while the cost of new house purchase loans rose significantly in August.

The central bank’s analysis suggests that the core issue for Cypriot savers is not that lending rates are especially high by euro area standards. Rather, it is that interest rate changes have been passed through to deposits far less fully than elsewhere in the currency union.

Uol
eCredo
Aretilaw firm
The Future Forbes Realty Global Properties

Become a Speaker

Become a Speaker

Become a Partner

Subscribe for our weekly newsletter