The Dutch Data Protection Authority has fined Uber €825 million over how the company deactivated driver accounts, according to Reuters. The penalty is the second-largest issued under the European Union’s General Data Protection Regulation.
According to the regulator, Uber used automated processes to deactivate some drivers without adequate warning or sufficient human oversight. Deputy chair Monique Verdier said Uber had “committed serious infringements.”
Follow THE FUTURE on LinkedIn, Facebook, Instagram, X and Telegram
Regulator Challenges Uber’s Automated Decisions
Dutch regulators said some drivers were permanently deactivated without human review. Uber disputed the finding, saying most suspensions are temporary and permanent deactivations require human oversight.
Drivers can also appeal account decisions, Uber said, while the company confirmed it will challenge the fine. “We strongly disagree with this decision and disproportionate fine,” an Uber spokesperson told Reuters.
EU data protection rules require additional safeguards for certain automated decisions with significant consequences. The case centers on whether Uber’s use of automated systems met those requirements when account decisions could affect drivers’ ability to earn a living.
Case Began With Driver Complaints
The dispute dates back to Brahim Ben Ali, a former Uber driver in France. After his account was deactivated in 2019, Ben Ali gathered testimony from 170 other drivers and brought the complaint to the Netherlands, where Uber has its European headquarters.
Swiss digital rights nonprofit PersonalData.io supported the drivers and helped them collect information about Uber’s deactivation process. Founder Paul-Olivier Dehaye said the case showed how account decisions can affect drivers’ income.
“A driver can complete a thousand journeys with satisfied passengers, but if just one person reports a very serious problem, the consequences can be enormous,” Dehaye said.
Uber Faces Further Regulatory Action
According to Dehaye, the €825 million penalty is the third fine the Dutch regulator has imposed on Uber. Previous penalties included a €290 million fine over the handling of drivers’ personal data and a separate €10 million penalty related to privacy violations.
Dehaye said he plans to pursue a class action seeking compensation for affected drivers. He is also launching StartClaims, a company focused on litigation and regulatory actions, initially involving Uber and potentially other gig-economy disputes.
Debate Over Algorithmic Management
The decision has renewed debate over how platforms use software to monitor and discipline workers. TechCrunch cited a blog post by Daring Fireball’s John Gruber arguing that the ruling could make it harder for Uber to use automated systems to identify drivers accused of misconduct.
Gruber said companies, rather than computers, ultimately set the rules behind disciplinary decisions. Dehaye disagreed, saying Uber can use human decision-makers but must accept responsibility for those decisions.
Uber plans to challenge the €825 million penalty, leaving the dispute to further regulatory and legal proceedings.







